735 S Dillard St, Winter Garden, FL 34787 Family owned & operated since 1982 Call (407) 656-2581
Choice Meats logoChoice MeatsEst. 1982 · Winter Garden
Winter Garden's neighborhood butcher

Fresh cut.
Fair priced.
Since 1982.

Choice Meats is a family-run butcher shop on South Dillard Street. Every steak, roast and chop is cut by people who know your name, and we'll cut it the way you like it.

40+Years on Dillard St
FreshCut to order
LocalFamily owned
Thanksgiving · Thursday, November 26
From our family to yours

Come celebrate Thanksgiving with us

Family owned since 1982, we’d be honored to be part of your table this year. Fresh Amish turkeys are $3.99/lb in 8–10, 10–12 and 18–24 lb sizes. Hold yours with a $25 deposit and pick it up Thanksgiving week. Quantities are limited, so reserve early.

At the counter

What we carry

Fresh ribeye steaks on butcher paper

Beef

USDA Choice Western beef: steaks, roasts, and ground beef made fresh in house.

Thick-cut bone-in pork chops on butcher paper

Pork

All-natural, lean, and tender. Center-cut chops, sirloin chops, roasts and more.

Fresh whole chicken and chicken thighs on butcher paper

Poultry

All-natural, hormone-free chicken: thighs, drumsticks, and more. Fresh turkeys for the holidays.

Choice Meats gift card on butcher paper with a wrapped package and a ribeye steak
Gift cards

The gift that always fits

Buy a Choice Meats gift card online in any amount and send it by email or text. It's good for anything at the counter.

Buy a Gift Card
Come see us

735 S Dillard St

Just south of downtown Winter Garden, with easy parking right out front.

Monday – Saturday9:00 am – 6:30 pm
Sunday10:00 am – 5:00 pm
Limited quantities
Thanksgiving 2026

Fresh Amish Turkeys $3.99/lb

Fresh Amish turkeys for Thanksgiving in Winter Garden. Reserve your size online or stop in to preorder, then pick up your bird Thanksgiving week and pay the balance at the counter.

Choice Meats flyer: Fresh Amish Turkeys, $3.99 per pound, 8 to 10, 10 to 12, and 18 to 24 pound sizes, $25 non-refundable deposit
  • Fresh Amish turkeys at $3.99/lb
  • Sizes: 8–10, 10–12, and 18–24 lb
  • $25 non-refundable deposit holds your bird
  • Pickup Thanksgiving week
How it works

Three steps to your bird

Reserve online

Choose a size range and a pickup day below, then pay a $25 deposit through our secure Square checkout.

We call to confirm

We'll call to confirm your size and pickup day. Prefer to do it in person? Stop in and preorder at the counter.

Pick up & pay the rest

Come by on your pickup day. Your turkey is weighed at $3.99/lb, your $25 comes off the total, and you pay the balance at the counter.

Reserve now

Hold your turkey

Quantities are limited, and the most popular sizes go first.

Fresh Amish turkey with autumn leaves and pumpkins
  • Price: $3.99/lb, by the actual weight of your bird
  • Deposit: $25, non-refundable, credited toward your turkey at pickup
  • Balance: paid in store at pickup
  • Prefer in person? Stop in at 735 S Dillard St to preorder

Round out the table

Golden Amish turkey pot pie

⚑ Add the sides and extras Veronica carries this year (for example, spiral ham, prime rib roast, stuffing, gravy, or fresh-made sausage for dressing). Mention any of them in your notes and we'll set them aside.

Turkey reservation

Takes about a minute. You'll pay the $25 deposit on the next screen.

Deposit due today$25.00

Secure checkout by Square. The $25 deposit is non-refundable and is credited toward your turkey at pickup. The final price is $3.99/lb by weight.

Almost done!

We've got your request: . Pay the $25 deposit to lock it in, and we'll call to confirm.

Pay $25 Deposit with Square

⚑ Placeholder: this button goes to Choice Meats' Square checkout link.

Questions

Turkey FAQ

How much will my turkey cost?

$3.99 per pound, by the actual weight of your bird. A 12-lb turkey comes to about $47.88, and your $25 deposit comes off that total at pickup.

When do I pick up?

Thanksgiving week. Choose your day on the form and we'll confirm it when we call. ⚑ Confirm exact pickup days and hours.

Is the deposit refundable?

No. The $25 deposit is non-refundable. It counts toward your turkey when you pick it up.

How big a turkey do I need?

A good rule of thumb is about 1¼ to 1½ pounds per person, a little more if you want leftovers.

Can you prep my bird?

⚑ If the counter can handle it, offer one option (spatchcocking or a brine kit) and list it here.

Gift cards

Give the gift of a great dinner

Choice Meats gift cards are delivered by email or text in seconds and are good for anything at the counter. They make an easy thank-you for clients, teachers, and the grill master in your life.

⚑ Placeholder: this button opens Choice Meats' Square eGift Card page.

Choice Meats · Est. 1982
$100
Choose an amount

Popular amounts

Any amount from ⚑ $10 to $500. You can schedule delivery for a birthday or holiday.

How it works

Easy to give, easy to use

  • Buy online and we email or text it to them, or to you to print
  • They show it at the counter on their phone
  • Use it over several visits; the balance carries over
  • Check a balance anytime at the counter or online
⚑ Holiday bonus (optional)

Buy $100, get a $10 bonus for you

Give a $100 gift card this season and get a $10 bonus card to use on your next visit. ⚑ Only run this after Veronica checks margins and the counter has tested redeeming gift cards.

⚑ Confirm the selection with Veronica

What we carry

The case changes with the season, so call ahead if you're after something specific. If we don't have it cut, we'll cut it for you.

Packaged fresh beef, pork and chicken in the Choice Meats meat case
Fresh ribeye steaks on butcher paper

Beef

  • USDA Choice Western beef
  • New York strip & ribeye ⚑
  • Mock tender steaks
  • Bottom round & chuck roasts
  • Fresh ground beef
Thick-cut bone-in pork chops on butcher paper

Pork

  • Center-cut pork chops
  • Rib-end & sirloin chops
  • Boneless thick & thin chops
  • Roasts ⚑
  • Sausage ⚑
Fresh whole chicken and chicken thighs on butcher paper

Poultry

  • All-natural, hormone-free chicken
  • Bone-in thighs
  • Drumsticks
  • Breasts & wings ⚑
  • Fresh holiday turkeys
Weekly specials

This week at the counter

Fresh deals every week. Follow us on Facebook for the latest specials, or call the shop.

Example specials

USDA Choice bottom round roast$6.99/lb
Center-cut pork chops$2.99/lb
Hormone-free chicken thighs$1.99/lb

⚑ Prices taken from September flyers. Replace each week, or swap in the current flyer image.

About & visit

A family shop since 1982

For over forty years, Choice Meats has been the place Winter Garden families go for fresh-cut meat and friendly service. We're still family owned and still behind the counter every day. ⚑ Veronica's story goes here: who started the shop and what makes it different.

Choice Meats storefront at 735 S Dillard St, Winter Garden

Hours & location

Choice Meats
735 S Dillard St
Winter Garden, FL 34787
(407) 656-2581

Monday – Saturday9:00 am – 6:30 pm
Sunday10:00 am – 5:00 pm
Thanksgiving Day⚑ Closed?
Call Directions Turkey